Goodfellas Pizza Sawgrass

Just moved to Sunrise from Boston and the pepperoni pizza tastes exactly like something you’d get from the North End at home. So happy we found you Goodfellas, keep up the good work. Muah! ❤❤

I’d totally recommend this place. My family and I love it so far. We recently moved to the area so we’ve only dined in once and it was so delicious. Everything is so fresh and flavorful. We just ordered for delivery yesterday and again, everything was on point. My only suggestion is if you’re ordering pick it up yourself. We used SLICE to order and it took 40 minutes to get to our house after the order had already said it was out for delivery (we live 4 minutes away). It may just be that there were multiple deliveries going out at once but that was just our experience.

Ordered and got the wrong pizza, they gave me cheese but charged me $25 for a special pizza then it was COLD!!! Crust was hard like if it was day old pizza. I fully support small business but not when they don’t offer good service. No answer after I called to complain. Will never order again.

Great lunch specials! Friendly staff. Beautiful ambiance. Great place! Only came for a random lunch but I will be back one day with a lovely date.

As an old regular to this location when it was Scuotto’s, I had very high expectations. Walking in, the furniture is completely different and the high tops all gone. You have options of booth style seating or bar seating. The menu is extensive and you can catch live music Thursday through Sunday.

We have ordered a few times and gave tried the pizza (delicious!), pasta ( mostly delightful) and the salads and rolls. Every time I’ve come here, the garlic rolls are burnt. Perhaps they call it well done, but it’s charred and not my preference. Of all the pasta, the shrimp scampi was my least favorite with a bland, over oily, sauce. The shrimp however, were plump and tender, though the tails still on. The wine menu leaves a lot to be desired but you can get some basic reds and whites.

Customer service was on par and Melissa was our favorite till she left for school. Overall, it’s a great spot for some delicious, and fast, Italian.